Law school professors from across the country are lambasting the
plan presented by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency for
re-opening its closed libraries, according to a joint letter released
today by Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility (PEER). The
law professors fault EPA for failing to fully restore services,
guarantee full public access or ensure professional librarian control
over valuable collections.
The April 26, 2008 letter, signed by 94 law professors from schools
stretching from the Carolinas to California, is addressed to key
congressional leaders and conveys the authors’ “profound
disappointment” in the six-page EPA report on library restoration
submitted to Congress on March 26, 2008, including –
- Political Control. “We view with alarm the
absence of any EPA commitment to have all aspects of its library plans
subject to review by qualified, non-governmental library professionals”;
- Only Partial Restoration.
“We are troubled by the Report’s…failure to explain why and how EPA’s
libraries will vary in size, target audience, subject focus and depth
of collection….We also decry the Agency’s failure to explain its plan
to allow some EPA libraries to be open to the public on an ‘appointment
only’ basis.”; and
- Vague Commitments.
“EPA’s Report is woefully lacking in detail, unresponsive to many of
the criticisms that were appropriately included in GAO’s February, 2008
reports on the Agency’s library mismanagement, and entirely devoid of a
needed commitment to restore EPA’s shuttered libraries to the levels of
service provided to the public and EPA’s staff prior to their closure.
The law professors’ concerns echo those raised by PEER, the agency’s
librarians, employee unions (which are pursuing unfair labor practice
charges), and agency specialists, including its enforcement attorneys.
“EPA simply needs to put back everything they dismantled; why is
that so hard?” asked PEER Associate Director Carol Goldberg. “The
political appointees at EPA should not be deciding, as they are now,
who gets access to what material.”
EPA had eliminated
access to agency libraries in 23 states, shut technical collections and
reduced hours and access in other libraries. This December, Congress
ordered EPA to re-open closed libraries. In its March report, the
agency indicated that it would complete a partial restoration by this
October.
Meanwhile, EPA has launched a series of meetings with media,
industry, environmental organizations and “other stakeholder groups” as
part of “a National Dialogue…to help EPA document the information needs
of various sectors …under the leadership of the Chief Information
Officer Molly O’Neill”, in the words of an invitation sent to PEER.
This National Dialogue will continue until the end of June.
SOURCE: Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility
April 28, 2008
Contact: Carol Goldberg (202) 265-7337